The Lucifer Effect by Philip Zimbardo  

Resisting Influence

Prepared by Philip Zimbardo and Cindy X. Wang

Cialdini’s Principles of Social Influence

Scarcity [Context: Competition]

The Basics

  • People assign more value to opportunities when they are less available—if there are fewer resources and less time to get them, we want it more

  • Principle holds true for two reasons:

    • Things that are difficult to attain are typically more valuable – availability of item can serve as a shortcut heuristic cue to its quality

    • As things become less accessible, we lose freedoms – respond to loss of freedoms by wanting to have them more than before

  • Optimizing conditions for scarcity principle:

    • Value newly scarce items more than items that have been restricted all along

    • Most attracted to scarce resources when we must compete with others for them – have an emotion-arousing quality that makes critical thinking difficult-- as in auctions where bidders will outbid each other and pay more than item is worth rather than to yield up the scarce item

How It’s Exploited
  • Use of this principle for profit can be seen in compliance techniques as ‘limited number’ and ‘deadline’ tactics in which persuaders try to convince us that access is restricted by amount or time.

  • Bush administration used a variation of this theme in justifying rush to war in Iraq: time is running out for Saddam unless we stop him now he will use his WMD against us

Best Defense
  • We should step back and assess the merits of the opportunity, the value of the item, the deal solely in terms of why we want it

  • We should aim to give as objective an evaluation of its personal value, and not overvalue it simply because it is scarce-- or has the appearance of being scarce.

©2006-2016, Philip G. Zimbardo

About the Book

About the Movie

About Phil Zimbardo

Stanford Prison Experiment

Celebrating Heroism

Resisting Influence


Other Links and Information

Jesus and Lucifer on Social Justice
By Rev. Jennifer Brooks
I was intrigued by television personality Glenn Beck's advice that Christians "run as fast as you can" from a church that has "social justice" on its website. Beck apparently sees "social justice" as something new, springing from Marxism and not only irrelevant but harmful to Christianity. Thinking about Beck’s advice, I asked myself, WWJD, "What Would...